Claude Makelele, Charlton Athletic 2004/05
The game didn’t matter; Chelsea were champions, ready to collect the Premier League trophy for the first time. Then, in the last minute, we were awarded a penalty and Claude Makelele, scoreless in his previous 93 games as a Blue, stepped up to take it. Now it mattered! Unsurprisingly, Maka’s effort was saved, but the rebound came straight back to him and he scuffed it in. Cue bedlam at the Bridge.